TalkAwhile - The Folk Corporation Forum

Artists => Fairport Convention => Topic started by: David W on December 13, 2005, 02:27:44 PM



Title: One from each album compilation
Post by: David W on December 13, 2005, 02:27:44 PM
You can choose one track from each FC studio album to make up your perfect set list / compilation - any offers?
I'll kick off with:

Time Will Show the Wiser
Meet on the Ledge
Genesis Hall
Tam Lin
Sir Patrick Spens
Journeyman's Grace
Sailors Aplhabet
Hens March ...
Hexamshire Lass
Restless
Cropredy Capers
Jams O'Donell
Widow of Westmoreland
Hiring Fair
Sigh Beg Sigh Mor
Red and Gold
Claudy Banks
Home is Where the Heart Is
Dangerous
Wood and the Wire
My Love is in America
Waiting for the tide to Come In

That at Cropredy would make me happy  [;-)

Jackdaw


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Speleologist (Robin) on December 13, 2005, 03:28:26 PM
My choice, following the same rules, would be:

The Lobster
The Lord is in this Place
A Sailor's Life
Crazy Man Michael
Sloth
Journeyman's Grace
Cell Song
The Plainsman
Polly on the Shore
One More Chance
Sandy's Song
The Bonny Bunch of Roses
Honour and Praise
Portmeirion
Dark Eyed Molly
The Wounded Whale
Closing Time
John Gaudie
The Dancer
I Wandered by a Brookside
Some Speciial Place

Also, if we allow Old, New, Borrowed, Blue (about half studio), then I'd choose Lalla Rookh from the studio section.

Thant's my choices at the moment, but it could easily be different another day.  ;)


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Speleologist (Robin) on December 13, 2005, 03:31:49 PM
And as an afterthought, I'd have "Now be Thankful" as it's on history, but not on any others until XXXV (At least in their original form).


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Keith on December 13, 2005, 04:09:20 PM
It shall be...

I don't know where I stand
Book song
Who knows where the time goes
Crazy man michael
Now be thankful
Dream song
Wizard of the worldly game
Polly on the shore
Rosie
One more chance
(nothing from Gottle - would prefer silence)
Eynsham poacher
Jack Orion
Wat Tyler
Portmeirion
Dark eyed Molly
Rhythm of the time
Red tide
John Gaudie (but would probably leave this album out)
Wood and the wire (ditto)
The crowd
The fossil hunter


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: tobeover2002 on December 13, 2005, 04:15:53 PM
I'd go for:

Time Will Show The Wiser
Tale In Hard Time
Fotheringay
Come All Ye
Poor Will And The Jolly Hangman (well, it's on the remastered version!)
The Journeyman's Grace
Breakfast In Mayfair
The Plainsman
Polly On The Shaw
One More Chance
The Eynsham Poacher
The Hair Of The Dog/Asbitme etc
Honour And Praise
The Gas Almost Works (honourable mention for Cat On The Mixer/Three Left Feet)
Dark Eyed Molly
The Wounded Whale
Slip Jigs And Reels
Lallah Rook
The Spanish Main
The Wood And The Wire
My Love Is In America

and I don't have the latest


David


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Folkie (Jen) on December 13, 2005, 04:51:51 PM
Keith... perfect, apart from The Crowd. I think I would replace it with "I wandered by a brookside" or "The light of day".

J


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Keith on December 13, 2005, 05:59:51 PM
Keith... perfect, apart from The Crowd. I think I would replace it with "I wandered by a brookside" or "The light of day".

J

I don't doubt you're right Jen - The Crowd's the only one I know from XXXV, but as my Dad has the album then it deserves a listen.

K.


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Pat Helms on December 13, 2005, 07:28:47 PM
I love these things!

Jack-of-Diamonds
Tale in a Hard Time
Autopsy
Come All Ye
Doctor of Physik
Sir William Gower
Breakfast in Mayfair
Matthew Mark Luke & John
Bring'Em DOwn
Dawn
Run Johnny Run
John Barleycorn
Wat Tyler
Portmerion
Summer Before the War
Wounded Whale
Naked Highwayman
Woodworm Swing - I can't remember anything else from this album - does that make me a bad person? :-\
Spanish Main
Wood & the Wire
Happy Man
Waiting for the Tide (?)

I left out all of the live releases and Hey Day.  Did I miss anyone besides those?


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Pat Helms on December 13, 2005, 07:32:17 PM
Gad!  I forgot Gottle-o-Geer!  How in the world did that happen?  Oh well............. ;)


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: The Happy Man (Rob) on December 13, 2005, 09:36:22 PM
These would be my choice:-

Jack O'Diamonds
Fotheringay
Autopsy
Farewell, Farewell
Sir Patrick Spens
The Journeyman's Grace
John Lee
Rosie
Polly On The Shore
White Dress
Adieu Adieu
Three Drunken Maidens
The Hiring Fair
Red And Gold
Ginnie
Slipjigs And Reels
Here's To Tom Paine
Close To You
My Love Is In America
I'm Already There


From Rob {:-)


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Neil on December 14, 2005, 04:25:07 AM
Okay here goes:

1.   It’s Alright Ma It’s Only witchcraft
2.   Tale In A Hard Time
3.   Sailor’s Life
4.   Lark In The Morning Medley
5.   Sloth
6.   Lord Marlborough
7.   Hanging Song
8.   The Plainsman
9.   Bring Em Down
10.   One More Chance
11.   Limeys lament
12.   General Taylor
13.   The Widow of Westmoreland
14.   Wat Tyler
15.   Jams O’Donnell’s Jigs
16.   Open The Door Richard
17.   Cup Of Tea etc.
18.   Slip jig’s and Reels
19.   Spanish Main
20.   The Good Fortunes
21.   Everything But The Skirl
22.   Willow Creek

Seems a lot easier than it is really.

Neil


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Speleologist (Robin) on December 14, 2005, 08:28:14 AM


Seems a lot easier than it is really.

Neil

I'd agree with that. I had a quick flick through the albums this morning, and many of my choices would have been different to yesterday.

e.g Honour & Praise versus Hiring Fair versus Wat Tyler. I could choose any one of those for Gladys Leap  :)


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Stephan on December 14, 2005, 11:53:32 AM
Grief! for one who only drops in now and again this is tough. And I cannot say I have all the albums.

The Lobster,Farewel Farewell,Fotheringhay(I live not so far away)Matty Groves,Tam Linn,Crazy man michael-well that`s a few.

Stephan


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Jan_ on December 15, 2005, 10:52:23 AM
As I don't have the stamina to do this all in one go, I'm going to do it in stages.

1.  I Don’t Know Where I Stand
2.  I’ll Keep It With Mine
3.  Genesis Hall
4.  Crazy Man Michael
5.  Now Be Thankful


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Jan_ on December 15, 2005, 11:28:22 PM
6.    Wizard Of The Worldly Game
7.    Breakfast In Mayfair
8.    Rosie
9.    Polly On The Shore
10.  One More Chance


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: NeilMcLaughlin on December 16, 2005, 01:37:09 AM
Time Will Show the Wiser
Nottamun Town
A Sailor's Life
Come All Ye
Doctor of Physick
Wizard of the Worldly Game
The Plainsman
Bring 'Em Down
One More Chance
When First Into This Country
Run Johnny Run
Jack O'Rion
Bird From the Mountain
Red and Gold
Claudy Banks
Slipjigs and Reels
Lalla Rookh
John Gaudie
Wood and the Wire
My Love is in America
I'm Already There

Really a tough choice on most albums to get down to choosing only one.  I skipped Babbacombe Lee as it still seems like you need the whole thing to make any of it as good as it really is. 


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Anna on December 16, 2005, 01:22:25 PM
What a challenge!  I don't have anything close to a full set of studio albums, but here's my "effort" anyway...  I tried to stick to the original content of the albums, apologies if I've accidentally included any bonus tracks...

Portfolio
Meet On The Ledge
Medley - Lark In the Morning etc
Flatback Caper
Angel Delight
Sailors Alphabet
To Althea From Prison
The Rose Hip
Slip Jigs & Reels
Don't Leave Too Soon
The Crowd
Westward

Yes, I know, there's a HUGE gap in the middle there...  Xmas CD wish-list is with all family, relations, friends and casual acquaintances...


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: abby (tank girl) on December 16, 2005, 01:26:32 PM
i dont know even half of these albumens but in the face of al the negativity for XXXV i would like to suggest chris leslie's tale of the blind fiddler.
genious!


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Jan_ on December 17, 2005, 12:59:52 AM
11.  The Frog Up The Pump
12.  James O'Donnel's Jig
13.  Bankrupted
14.  The Hiring Fair
15.  Sigh Beg Sigh Mor


Title: Re: One from each album compilation
Post by: Jan_ on December 18, 2005, 12:14:47 PM
16.  Red & Gold
17.  The Wounded Whale
18.  The Islands
19.  Sailing Boat
20.  The Lady Vanishes
21.  The Deserter
22.  I’m Already There

Phew!  Got there in the end.  A difficult but interesting task - thank you Jackdaw.   :)